PlainEV

Mini Aceman vs Smart #1

· Real-world figures, not WLTP

Mini Aceman
Photo: Alexander Migl, CC BY-SA 4.0

Mini Aceman

Aceman E

£29,060 · 143 mi

Wins 7 of 17

Smart #1
Photo: M 93, CC BY-SA 3.0 de

Smart #1

#1 Pure (MY24)

£29,960 · 155 mi

Wins 10 of 17

Our verdict

The Mini Aceman and Smart #1 are both electric SUVs in the small car class. The Mini Aceman starts at £29,060 in the UK and the Smart #1 at £29,960, comparing the cheapest version of each.

The Aceman is £900 cheaper to buy new (£29,060 against £29,960). On top of that, it uses less energy (3.7 mi/kWh against 3.3 mi/kWh).

The #1 goes further, with about 155 miles of real-world range against 143 for the Aceman. On top of that, it charges faster on a rapid charger (70 kW against 60 kW on average, 10–80%), has the bigger boot (338 litres against 300) and is quicker, doing 0–62 mph in 6.7 s against 7.9 s.

There's little between them on warranty length (3 years).

Choose the Mini Aceman if you want the lower price and lower running costs and the Smart #1 if you want the longest range and quicker charging stops.

Written from the figures below, comparing the cheapest UK version of each. Other versions can differ: open them in Compare to swap versions.

Mini AcemanSmart #1

Price

Price new
£29,060 (best)on sale now
£29,960on sale now
Used from (estimated)
£13,800 (best)2024 car
£14,2002024 car
Price per mile of range
£203
£193 (best)

Range and efficiency

Real-world range
143 mi230 km, estimate
155 mi (best)250 km, estimate
Range today, used (estimated)
about 137 mi2024 car, est.
about 149 mi (best)2024 car, est.
Efficiency
3.7 mi/kWh (best)167 Wh/km, estimate
3.3 mi/kWh188 Wh/km, estimate
Range with one 15-min stop
151 mi243 km
174 mi (best)280 km

Charging

Rapid charging
60 kW10–80% average
70 kW (best)10–80% average
Home (AC) charging
11 kW (best)
7 kW
Charging plug
Type 2 CCS
Type 2 CCS
Vehicle-to-load (V2L)
No
Yes (best)
Vehicle-to-home (V2H)
No
No
Vehicle-to-grid (V2G)
No
No

Battery

Usable battery
38.5 kWh
47 kWh (best)
Battery chemistry
NCM (nickel manganese cobalt)
LFP (lithium iron phosphate)
Heat pump
Yes
Yes

Body and performance

Body style
SUV
SUV
Size class
B · Small car
B · Small car
Seats
5
5
Drive
Front-wheel drive
Rear-wheel drive
0–62 mph
7.9 s0–100 km/h
6.7 s (best)0–100 km/h
Weight
1,720 kg
1,855 kg

Size

Length
4.08 m13 ft 5 in
4.27 m14 ft
Width (without mirrors)
1.75 m5 ft 9 in
1.82 m6 ft
Width with mirrors
1.99 m6 ft 6 in
2.03 m6 ft 8 in
Height
1.51 m5 ft
1.64 m5 ft 4 in
Wheelbase
2.61 m8 ft 7 in
2.75 m9 ft

Practicality and safety

Boot space
300 litres
338 litres (best)
Towbar available
Yes (best)
No
Towing (braked)
750 kg (best)
Not approved
Max payload
525 kg (best)people and luggage
425 kgpeople and luggage
Euro NCAP rating
5 stars
5 stars

Warranty (UK)

Car warranty
3 yearsunlimited miles
3 yearsunlimited miles
Battery warranty
8 years100,000 miles, 70% capacity
8 years (best)125,000 miles, 70% capacity
Passes to next owner
Yes
Yes

Availability

Status
On sale new
On sale new
Model years
2024 on
2024 on

Green marks the better figure in each row. Range is a real-world estimate, not WLTP. Used prices are estimates. Warranty terms are UK terms from each maker’s website.

Every version

Mini Aceman

Smart #1